Brian Hanna looks at the key components of the public
health review in Northern Ireland
In 1998, devolved government was returned to Northern Ireland
following the Good Friday Agreement and the executive of the devolved
administration (which is currently in suspension) produced its vision
for a cohesive, inclusive and just society in the "programme
for government". This has five overarching priorities - one
of which is "working for a healthier people". Given the
high level of poor health suffered by many of the province's populace,
particularly those from the lower socio-economic sectors of society,
this was a welcome and crucial aspect of the programme.
This priority committed the Northern Ireland Government to working
to improve the health of all the people of Northern Ireland and
to reducing health inequalities. As already discussed, in March
2002, the executive launched its health strategy - Investing for
health - central to which is the commitment to ensuring equality
of opportunity and tackling social disadvantage, recognising that
it is through improving the living and working conditions of the
most disadvantaged in society that great improvements in health
can be made. The strategy is also consistent with the Government's
commitment to its new "targeting of social need and equality"
agendas.
There is much that should enthuse and motivate environmental health
practitioners in all of this. Investing for health sets out a strategy
which is as much about disease prevention and health promotion as
it is about the provision of adequate clinical services. It carries
within it a strong message about the social and economic factors
which impact upon the health of the people of Northern Ireland.
This fits well with the enhanced role for EHPs in public health
as set out in the vision statement Environmental health 2012.
A decision to review the public health function in Northern Ireland
arose out of the Investing for health strategy process. A steering
group chaired by the chief medical officer for Northern Ireland,
Dr Henrietta Campbell, has been set up to carry out this work and
is comprised of the following people:
Dr H E Campbell, chief medical officer, DHSSPS (chair);
Mrs Mary Black, project manager, North and West Belfast Health
Action Zone;
Mr Michael Bloomfield, principal officer, investing for health
team, DHSSPS;
Dr J A Muir Gray, programmes director of the National Screening
Committee, Institute of Health Sciences;
Professor Sian Griffiths, president of the Faculty of Public
Health Medicine;
Mr Brian Hanna, president of the Chartered Institute of Environmental
Health;
Miss Judith Hill, chief nursing officer, DHSSPS;
Mrs Deirdre Kenny, director of health development, DHSSPS;
Dr Paula Kilbane, chief executive, Eastern Health and Social
Services Board; * Dr Liz Mitchell, principal medical officer,
DHSSPS;
Dr Mary O'Mahoney, head of communicable diseases branch, Department
of Health, London;
Professor John Watson, director of public health, Northern
Health and Social Services Board; and
Dr Jane Wilde, director, Institute of Public Health in Ireland.
The terms of reference of the review, due to be completed by February
2004, are as follows:
to assess the current state of the public health function in
Northern Ireland;
to examine current arrangements and activities in relation
to the ability to deliver current and likely future objectives
for public health in Northern Ireland;
to examine the relationship between health in Northern Ireland
and the rest of the UK and Ireland and beyond in relation to organisation
and development;
to establish an agreed vision of the role of the public health
function in Northern Ireland; and
to make recommendations to strengthen the future provision
of the public health function in Northern Ireland.
Consultants have been appointed to support the steering group
(Capita Business Services Ltd) and its working methodology and
timetable has been agreed. The work, which began at the first
meeting of the steering group on 19 June 2003, will take about
nine months to complete. It has been agreed that the project be
divided into two main phases of work:
establishing the current status of the public health function;
and
developing a blueprint for the future public health function.
According to Dr Campbell, "the desire to improve public health
was the primary driving force for many of the early environmental
improvements in our society. In recent times, however, the subjects
have tended to drift apart, both conceptually and in our institutions.
The review is an opportunity for the environmental health service
to consider its place in improving and protecting public health
in the future."
A key part of phase one will be a document review, and both Agendas
for change and Environmental health 2012 have been submitted to
the consultants for inclusion in this review. There will also be
key policy/strategy scene setting meetings and EHPs will be directly
involved in the discussions through the CIEH director in Northern
Ireland, Gary McFarlane, the Northern Ireland Centre of CIEH and
the Northern Ireland Chief Environmental Health Officers Group.
Local government in Northern Ireland will also be involved in the
discussions.
The first meeting of the steering group was extremely positive
and one important idea to emerge, and which will be explored further,
is the possible creation of a multi-disciplinary young professionals
group that could act as a sounding board for emerging ideas and
suggestions. Such a group would contain a number of young EHPs.
The steering group considered it important that the views and ideas
of young professionals from across the various public health disciplines
should feature strongly in the review process.
Running parallel with the Northern Ireland public health review
is another important review - the review of public administration.
This was begun by the devolved government and is well advanced,
although no public report has yet emerged from it. The CIEH (NI)
has made a submission to the review team and Gary McFarlane has
been actively involved in promoting and pursuing the profession's
interests in relation to it. The outcome of this major review of
the province's public administration arrangements will have an impact
on local government and the role and place of EHPs within it. It
will therefore need to connect with the review of public health.
This point was raised at the inaugural meeting of the public health
steering group and it was agreed that close liaison be maintained
with those charged with carrying out the review of public administration.
Both of these important reviews will, of course, need to be considered
by whatever political regime is charged with governing Northern
Ireland. Will it fall to direct rule ministers, or local ministers
in a restored Northern Ireland Executive, accountable to the people
of Northern Ireland through a directly elected Assembly, to decide
the future arrangements for both public administration and public
health? Let us hope that it is the latter.
Either way, EHPs should approach the review of public health in
a positive frame of mind and bear in mind that they are faced with
an opportunity and not a threat. The review has the potential to
produce an outcome which will enable EHPs to play a full and active
role, in partnership with others, in the promotion and enhancement
of public health in Northern Ireland. That is surely something that
all EHPs should welcome.