Concerns about the lack of srategic planning within environmental
health departments to improve health and wellbeing led Sam
Knox to press for change
In the autumn of 2001, the director of environmental services
from one of the local councils in the Southern Group Environmental
Health Committee asked about the current state of environmental
health planning in Northern Ireland. Plans had historically been
more operational than strategic and evoked little or no response
from the five local councils' elected members when tabled for discussion.
As group chief environmental health officer, I was concerned about
the lack of strategic planning to improve health and wellbeing within
environmental health departments and the lack of ownership and interest
among EHPs at grass roots level. One question specifically came
to mind: "Whatever happened to Agendas for change and its aspirations
and guiding principles?"
Determined to introduce change to the whole planning process and
having established that staff wanted to embrace partnership working
to improve public health, a meeting was arranged in London in November
2001 with Ian MacArthur, who was then co-ordinating the Commission
on Environmental Health, to ask why limited progress had been made
since 1997 in achieving the principles of Agendas for change.
Following lengthy discussion, Mr MacArthur agreed to come to Northern
Ireland and assist in the challenge to change hearts and minds towards
a more strategic-based planning process, embracing public health
and securing ownership at all levels within the profession in the
southern group.
The process began in February 2002, in a seminar comprising elected
members representing the five councils, the directors of environmental
services and senior officers from the Southern Health and Social
Services Board (SHSSB), with presentations on health and wellbeing
issues. Part of the presentation included a sketch on the EHO's
work, which concentrated initially on the traditional approach to
investigating a complaint about severe mould growth in a high-rise
block of flats.
The sketch entitled "The mould of the new EHO" featured
high on comedy but, nevertheless, had a serious message underpinning
the performance. It considered the traditional advice of "turn
up the heat and open the windows" and then in contrast demonstrated
the investigating officer enquiring about health problems, which
could be attributed to the housing conditions. A commitment was
given to seeking help and assistance from other health colleagues
including the director of public health and the local health action
zone manager.
The following day, a workshop on the EHO's role in public health
was held as a precursor to a series of planning workshops for all
staff. There was a strong commitment from members to engage in public
health improvements but also a stark realisation that dedicated
workers were required and plans needed to embrace the new agenda.
A planning template was produced and presented to all staff across
the five councils. At that stage, each department developed their
own vision, mission and key objectives, linked to their corporate
plans.
The final plans were presented to the five councils and were received
favourably by elected members. Councillors recognised that environmental
health practitioners have a unique contribution to make through
their primary focus of maintaining health as well as pursuing their
predominantly technical and enforcement roles. Many welcomed the
shift in policy in the new plan towards local action aimed at reducing
health inequalities and improving future health and wellbeing of
local communities.
Simultaneously, the new Investing for health strategy was launched
in March 2002. Analysis of the determinants of ill health, as laid
down in the strategy, illustrated that EHPs clearly had a major
contribution to make in reducing health inequalities. Although the
revised plans identified objectives, which would assist in the reduction
of health inequalities using existing resources, it was clear that
a dedicated resource would be necessary to make significant impact
across the services of the five councils.
Working in partnership with the councils' chief executives, the
directors of environmental services and the SHSSB's chief officers,
a proposal has emerged for the joint appointments of three Investing
for health officers. These capacity building posts, which will be
jointly funded by the councils, the SHSSB and the Southern Group
Environmental Health Committee, will switch the councils' service
delivery towards the objectives of the new regional Investing for
health plan.
This approach has been adopted despite the absence of wellbeing
and community planning powers in Northern Ireland. It has only been
achieved through the visionary approach and co-operation of the
councils and the SHSSB's senior management and is currently attracting
interest and debate within other health board regions in Northern
Ireland.
Sam Knox is group chief environmental health officer at the
Southern Group Environmental Health Committee and chair of the Northern
Ireland Centre.