Clement Ramsdale and Keith Snow look at the susceptibility
of the British Isles and parts of France to colonisation by
the notorious tiger mosquito.
The southeast Asian "tiger mosquito" - Aedes (Stegomyia)
albopictus - is a notorious vector of dengue and other potentially
life-threatening or disabling human and animal diseases. During
the past several years it has taken advantage of international commerce
to spectacularly expand its distribution and is now well established
in parts of North America and Europe.
Mosquitoes of the genus Aedes have adopted an effective strategy
for survival through long unfavourable periods. Their eggs are laid
in dried-out places and do not hatch until soaked by rising water
levels, often many months later. This period of delayed development
during the egg stage appears to be obligatory and eggs are never
laid directly onto a water surface. Aedes species belonging to the
subgenus Stegomyia exploit a particular larval niche, loosely termed
the "container habitat". This type of habitat includes
holes in trees as well as domestic and industrial items such as
water storage containers, old discarded vessels, opened tins, and
litter capable of holding water after rain or other source of flooding.
In addition to the tiger mosquito, the subgenus Stegomyia includes
the "yellow fever mosquito" - Aedes aegypti - and other
tropical species which together transmit many disease organisms.
This has given them world-wide notoriety. Though both develop in
containers, the habitats of Ae. aegypti and Ae. albopictus are not
identical. While the former readily exploits indoor water collections
and is common in urban areas in the tropics and subtropics, the
latter invariably develops outside buildings and favours suburban
or rural wooded situations. The tiger mosquito is an opportunistic
feeder, willing to take blood from a variety of hosts, and is well
suited to transmit to humans a number of viruses with mammal and
bird reservoirs.
Before the advent of an effective vaccine, the control of the
yellow fever mosquito was a major item in many tropical and sub-tropical
public health budgets. Until decimated by the malaria eradication
campaigns after the Second World War, populations of this mosquito
could be found as far north as about the 10°C January isotherm,
and the species was present in some southern European port areas.
Although this mosquito is unable to withstand the cold winters experienced
in most of Europe, there are records of summer outbreaks of yellow
fever in temperate regions, including southern England and southern
Wales, during the 18th and 19th centuries.(6) In all these episodes,
the disease was transmitted by the mosquito developing in stored
water on board ships arriving from tropical ports.
The yellow fever mosquito and the tiger mosquito both originated
in the "old world". Because of its predilection for water
storage containers, the yellow fever mosquito became increasingly
cosmotropical with man's growing ability to cross previously unnavigable
seas, and seems to have established itself in the "new world"
at an early stage of settlement by people of European and African
stock. It posed a major threat to the building of the Panama Canal
and necessitated expensive mosquito control operations over a large
area in the southern United States, Central America, the Caribbean
and the northern half of South America. Though eradication campaigns
restricted its distribution in the Americas, it is still well established
in many places. It has not been recorded in southern Europe for
many years, but public health departments throughout the Mediterranean
are aware of the danger of its re-appearance.
In contrast, until comparatively recently, the distribution of
the tiger mosquito remained restricted to a fairly well defined
region in the Far East and islands of the Indian Ocean and the western
Pacific. However, it tolerates lower minimum temperatures and is
present in parts of northern China and Japan where the yellow fever
mosquito is absent. The past two or three decades have seen the
establishment and rapid growth of a lucrative international trade
in used tyres and these are now routinely transported by ship between
widely separated industrial regions of the world. Stacked tyres
exposed to the elements before and after transportation constitute
attractive egg-laying sites for the tiger mosquito. Tyres now play
a major role in aiding the rapid spread of this mosquito throughout
the world.
Larvae of the tiger mosquito were first discovered in tyres imported
into the United States during the 1970s but it was not until 1985
that an established breeding population was found in Houston, Texas.
This was soon followed by the discovery of breeding populations
in other, widely separated localities. Established populations of
the species are now known from 674 counties in 24 states, all east
of the Rocky Mountains and as far north as Missouri, Illinois, Indiana
and Ohio. The mosquito was found in tyres near Minneapolis (Minnesota)
in 1991, 1996, 1997 and 1999. The first three infestations were
successfully dealt with; information regarding the last is not yet
available.
In Europe, larvae of the tiger mosquito were discovered in tyres
at a number of widely separated sites in Albania between August
and October, 1979. The initial infestation was probably at a rubber
factory adjacent to the port of Durrës (Durazzo), from where
it was sent in tyres to recapping plants in different parts of the
country. At that time, Albania was diplomatically and commercially
isolated from the rest of Europe (including Russia), the Americas
and all countries trading with the western world. Thus, the species
was probably introduced directly from China, the only country with
which Albania had links during the 1970s.(1,2) Breeding populations
of the same species were later discovered in several places in Italy,
first in northern and then in western port areas. All of these Italian
populations seem to have arrived in tyres imported from the United
States.(3,4) The species is now established over a wide area in
Italy.(7)
Elsewhere in the world the distribution of the tiger mosquito
has expanded to include Hawaii and other Pacific islands south to
New Zealand, and encompasses New Guinea, Indonesia and parts of
continental Africa. In addition to eggs, live larvae, pupae and
adults were discovered in shipments into New Zealand from Japan.
Could the tiger mosquito become established in Britain? Studies
of cold hardiness and distributional data from Asia and North America
indicate that the natural northerly limits of the distribution of
this species are set by the -5°C cold month isotherm. This includes
large parts of Europe, particularly where maritime influences prevail,
which has led to the conclusion that the British Isles and the Atlantic
and Channel coasts of France are susceptible to colonisation by
this mosquito.(5)
Following the discovery of the tiger mosquito in Italy, a programme
of surveillance was set up in the adjacent French Riviera in 1992.
Though several indigenous nuisance mosquitoes were present this
particular mosquito was not detected. However, in October 1999,
larvae of the tiger mosquito were found at a used tyre depot near
the village of Orne, some 30 miles south of the port of Caen in
Normandy.(8) It is too early to ascertain whether or not the species
is established in Normandy, but it is now a proven fact that it
is capable of reaching there, with consequent implications about
the vulnerability of this country. Caen is linked to Portsmouth
by ferry. Nevertheless, consignments of tyres constitute the most
probable means of entry into Britain, as has happened in other parts
of the world.
It would seem only prudent, therefore, for local health and/or
environmental authorities to make a register of companies participating
in the international tyre trade and to arrange for monitoring of
the presence of the tiger mosquito in and around tyre storage premises.
Given that tyres are regularly transported throughout Britain, such
a survey must include the whole of the country.
Concern about this dispersal goes beyond the addition of another
mosquito to our native fauna. Since its arrival in North America,
the tiger mosquito has been connected to the transmission of Potosi,
Cache Valley, LaCrosse, Eastern Equine Encephalitis, Keystone and
Tensaw viruses, as well as the infective stages of heart worm (Dirofilaria
spp.). Further, experimental work indicates it is a competent vector
of numerous Alphaviruses (Chikungunya, Eastern Equine Encephelitis,
Mayaro, Ross River, Western Equine Encephalitis, Venezuelan Equine
Encephalitis, Sindbis), Flaviviruses (Dengue serotypes 1, 2, 3,
and 4, Japanese Encephalitis, West Nile, Yellow Fever) and Bunyaviruses
(Jamestown Cañon, Keystone, LaCrosse, Oropouche, Potosi,
Rift Valley Fever, San Angelo, Trivittatus).
This country is, so far, remarkably free of mosquito-borne arboviruses,
but several are widespread in continental Europe, even as far north
as Scandinavia. European mosquito-borne viruses are zoonoses and
may be divided into bird associated (eg West Nile, Sindbis and the
Bunyavirus Lednice) and animal associated (eg the Bunyaviruses Tahyna,
Inkoo and Batai). Clinical symptoms of these viral infections range
from merely flu-like to meningo-encephalitis and haemorrhagic fever,
but are not virus specific and reliable diagnosis must be based
on serological tests.
It is not suggested that devastating outbreaks of mosquito-borne
viruses are imminent here. However, probabilities of arbovirus transmission
in this country will increase following establishment and proliferation
of the tiger mosquito and these probabilities might further increase
should predicted climate change lead to generally warmer conditions.
References
1. Adhami, J and Murati, N (1987) "Presence of the mosquito
Aedes albopictus in Albania". Revista Myekesore 1, 13-16. [In
Albanian]
2. Adhami, J and Reiter P (1998) "Introduction and establishment
of Aedes (Stegomyia) albopictus Skuse (Diptera, Culicidae) in Albania".
Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association 14, 340-343.
3. Dalla Pozza, G and Majore, G (1992) "First record of Ae.
albopictus establishment in Italy". Journal of the American
Mosquito Control Association 8, 318-320.
4. Della Torre, A C, Bomboi, C and Cancrini, G (1992) "Estensione
dell'areale di Aedes albopictus in Italia". Primo reperto della
specie in Italia centrale. Parassitologia 34, 143-146.
5. Mitchell C J (1995) "Geographic spread of Aedes albopictus
and potential for involvement in arbovirus cycles in the Mediterranean
basin". Journal of Vector Ecology 20, 44-58.
6. Ramsdale, C D. and Snow, K.R. (1995) Mosquito control in Britain.
University of East London Publications. Dagenham, 100 pp.
7. Romi, R, Luca, M di and Majori, D (1999) "Current status
of Aedes albopictus and Ae. atropalpus in Italy". Journal of
the American Mosquito Control Association 15, 425-427.
8. Schaffner, F and Karsh, S (1999) "Aedes albopictus discovered
in France". Society for Vector Ecology Newsletter 30, 11.
Clement Ramsdale can be contacted at: Varndean Lodge, London Road,
Brighton BN1 6YA or by e-mail at clem.ramsdale@claranet.co.uk
Keith Snow can be contacted at the Department of Environmental Sciences,
University of East London, Romford Road, London E15 4LZ and by e-mail
at k.r.snow@uel.ac.uk